Dear All,
It is in response to the blasphemous book and extremely incorrect narrations of the self-styled scholar, Sujit Das, the cursed. Though we have already pointed out the basic fallacies in Sujit's account of the most sublime personality of Islam and the religious world, yet it is necessary to dissect the inherent weaknesses and convoluted inaccuracies in his recent email, which he tries to wrap up in a technological language in order to give an impression of scholarship and research. His this recent email to all of us was preceded by an email to me on August 06,2012,with only one word, "FUCK OFF'', which is a name calling device, and not an academic approach. I didn't react to that as it was expected of him and his obnoxious frustration with a scholarly style, rather I would like to comment on his recent email, again a sign of his malicious nature and non-academic attitude. Lets have a point by point review of his recent email.
- According to Sujit, the religion of Islam is defenceless, vulnerable to collapse and a failed religion. Can anyone believe in this none-sense claim about a religion which has survived more than fourteen centuries and which is one of the fastest growing religions of the world at the time being, and which has a splendid civilization to its credit? Just read the books of Prof Philip K Hitti, AR Gibb, Gibbon, and Mongomery Watt on the subject. I have quoted all important classical works in my article against another blasphemous writer, Abul Kasem, in detail, which is available on our website of Pakistan Society of Criminology. Sujit doesn't produce any thing new in his misleading account of Islam and the Holy Prophet Muhammad(PBUH),but basically reproduces some of the old crusade time allegations of biggotted and disgruntled elements of that time, in a new wordings---old wine in the new bottle, but the same had long been discarded by the truth seeking and impartial orientalists and scholars of the west in the last few centuries like Prof Hitti, and the author of the Heroes and Heroeworship (the book is available online).In the latter, the reader may find many such old discarded stories which now Sujit wants us to believe in his self-created phraseology.
- According to Sujit,his findings are based on his research and psychological theory. I ask that to how many important religious personalities of the past Sujit has applied this methodology? What about Jesus the Christ? Buddah? Confucius? Tao? Moses? Ibraham? Any findings of Sujit on this topic? What image of God they presented if the image presented by the Holy Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) was his own and not divinely vouchsafed to him, as Sujit falsely narrates to us? Has Sujit applied his own research methodology to his own findings and delusions? How far he stands his own theory? Sujit puts his research methodology on the bases of a Mythological Narcissus(malignant Narcissism is the blasphemous word he uses for the Holy Prophet, PBUH). Can one expect a balanced and rational theory on the bases of a mythological figure? What is its soundness in an academic world if a research itself is based on a pre-historic mythology? How many such patients Sujit has studied on this methodology and how many of them in the history have announced to be the Messengers of God and brought to the world a complete system, a viable civilization and who spoke against darkness,superstitions, ignorance, religious persecution, and human rights violations, and whose religions preached light, tolerance, learning, and wisdom when maximum of the globe was passing through the Ages of Darkeness? Can Sujit quote a few such examples? The religion of the Holy Prophet (PBUH) has produced far excellent personalities, scholars, writers and scientists than Sujit can think of? Were and are they all so imbecile and deceived to follow a religion of lunacy as Sujit wants us to believe? If we accept the account of Sujit, at least a world population of more than 1 billion is following a religion of lunacy, delusion and of a narcissist, a dreadful realization, and the world may need a million of psychologists to treat them? Can you believe in this none-sense? I don't know how the publishers print such baseless and self-styled books, which itself portray the delusions of its authors and which demand their treatment, instead regarding them as a sound author.
- The personality of the Holy Prophet(PBUH) has been described in full light, not by his follows but by the opponents, that too in a very high sounding words, and about which high quality books are available everywhere. However, lets see his 'private motives' as Sujit claims falsely. How much worldly assets the Holy Prophet(PBUH) left at the time of his death? Did he live a princely life or he prayed, ''O GOG, I lived with the poor and would like to be amongst them on the Day of Resurrection". His life was an open book, and he said,'' what you see of my acts in secrecy, propagate it in open''. Can any self-centered man or any leader in the world say so to openly describe about his private life, and that he feels not hiding any part of his life from public scrutiny as he firmly believes that all his conduct is divinely controlled and made a good example for his followers? Who can offer himself for such an accountability especially in a very hostile circumstances in Makkah and Madinah? A person who has never told a lie in matters of ordinary people, how can he make a wrong statement about God? What image of God you get when you see that He remained silent when one of His creation was deluding His masses in His name for so many years and till the time one cursed Sujit Das discovered after 1400 years? What a joke in the name of psychology and what a wastage of time by this blasphemous man and his malicious book? I don't know how a psychologist can diagnose a person who lived a 100 years ago with neurotic disorders, delusion, narcissism etc, especially when he invented things, made a system, introduced new theories, did excellent poetry, wrote wonderful prose, published marvelous research, preached humanism or conquered continents? Can Sujit apply his fallacious and fabricated methodology to Plato, Aristotle, Alexander, King Henry, George Washington, Benjamin ranklin, Churchill,
Newton , Einstein, Copernicus,Edison , Napoleon, Dostoevsky, Will Durant and many of the like. Now who doesn't know that the followers of the Holy Prophet (PBUH) include a list of many such great personalities. Can a lunatic create such great people with his message? Sujit might know these things but currently, bashing Islam and its most respected personality is one of the cash business of these addicts of hate speech, esp., the Indians, Israelis and Hindu Bengalis, branded falsely as free thinkers. It is because of these perverted free thinkers that the misgivings and distrust is promoted between the west and Islam, whereas it is now high time to look for common points between Islam and the rest, as rightly advised by the Holy Book of Quran. We need an effective inter-faith dialogue so to push human civilization in a progressive way for the mutual existence and respect amongst the world community of religions. People like Sujit Das are a bad name and a dirty barrier to such peace efforts in the world.
- Lastly, let me ask Sujit, the cursed, that what is his contribution to the world and humanity? And let me ask, that has he diagnosed his own father and forefathers on the same psudoe methodology of mythological narcissism to know that of what diseases his parents might have been suffering, of whom he is born and likely be trained and educated by them? I was not a very staunch practicing Muslim before reading his stupid narrations but his false propaganda re-enforced my faith, conviction and belief in the purity, grandeur and innocence of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (Peace Be Upon Him).Those who will read his blasphemous book will definitely see that his/her faith in Islam will be strengthened than weakened as his bad intentions are glaringly propagandist and malicious. Anyone who wants to read his book must read my account of his book and also my article on Abul Kasem, given in article section of the Pakistan Society of Criminology website, which disrupts the misleading web of these blasphemous writers.
with best regards.
--
Fasihuddin (PSP)|
Director, Human Rights, Research and Development,
Central Police Office (CPO), QUETTA, Baluchistan.
President| Pakistan Society of Criminology &
Editor-in-Chief|Pakistan Journal of Criminology (PJC).
Tel: +92 91 560 2544 (Office)
Cell: +92 313 595 4055
__._,_.___
Editor,
Tariq Khattak.
0300-9599007 and 0333-9599007
Tariqgulkhattak@gmail.com
Tariq Khattak.
0300-9599007 and 0333-9599007
Tariqgulkhattak@gmail.com
.
__,_._,___
0 comments:
Post a Comment
Gujranwalafun@Aol.com
Gujranwala@windiowslive.com